OnlyCuffsOnlyCuffsarchive search
The Forum at Handcuffs.Org

Bean Giant Handcuffs

7 visible archived posts · 7 preserved total · topic ID 1910
Original topic ↗Recovered images
Andrew 30 Mar 2007
#1
A friend of mine recently gave me a set of Bean Giant handcuffs. Not being a handcuff collector myself, I am interested in the best way to sell them. Is there an easy way for them to be evaluated by an expert so as to verify their authenticity?
Stan Willis 30 Mar 2007
#2
There are many "experts" on this forum who can tell the real thing from a reproduction. Post a picture and note any markings and you will get lots of information, and maybe even some offers.
Stan
Andrew 30 Mar 2007
#3
A friend of mine recently gave me a set of Bean Giant handcuffs. Not being a handcuff collector myself, I am interested in the best way to sell them. Is there an easy way for them to be evaluated by an expert so as to verify their authenticity?
I have included three pics that will hopefully help. I have both a short key and an extended key (that doesn't fit properly) that were made by a locksmith.

These cuffs were passed on to me by Dan MacMillan, better known for his invention of the MacMillan Switch, a card trick featured in the movie "Shades."

Any help will be appreciated.



Edgeplay_Cgo 30 Mar 2007
#4
A friend of mine recently gave me a set of Bean Giant handcuffs. Not being a handcuff collector myself, I am interested in the best way to sell them. Is there an easy way for them to be evaluated by an expert so as to verify their authenticity?
Nice pair!

Handcuffs aren't an item that is commonly reproduced, with the notable exception of Ian McColl's superlative work. I believe he stamps his name on most of his work.

It looks like your photos are of authentic Bean Giants. I look for a few indicators, none of which are easy to fake.

The patina on the steel or plating looks like something that has developed over the decades. It's a subtle and shallow chemical change that affects the surface of the steel, partily oxidation, partly something else.

The tiny rust spots that remain, appear to be of long duration. The pitting under them is quite deep, and they have a different look from shallow surficial rust.

The edges that were sharp when new, are subtly and unevenly rounded from casual day to day wear. There are tiny dings and dents that come from every day wear. Those are also soft and subtle.

The real experts here can look at the fine points of the lines, and declare them authentic or not. That's out of my league.
Michael Lee 01 Apr 2007
#5
A friend of mine recently gave me a set of Bean Giant handcuffs. Not being a handcuff collector myself, I am interested in the best way to sell them. Is there an easy way for them to be evaluated by an expert so as to verify their authenticity?
Great Cuff

I am surprised to see that there is not an issue date stamped....Are you sure this is not a repro ? as the condition from the photo looks almost pristene

Michael Lee
Stan Willis 01 Apr 2007
#6
A friend of mine recently gave me a set of Bean Giant handcuffs. Not being a handcuff collector myself, I am interested in the best way to sell them. Is there an easy way for them to be evaluated by an expert so as to verify their authenticity?
There are Bean Giants that are totally unmarked. The ones I have seen are a little larger than the marked ones, and could be an early model or more likely were made by a different company.
Stan
The Amazing Michael 02 Apr 2007
#7
A friend of mine recently gave me a set of Bean Giant handcuffs. Not being a handcuff collector myself, I am interested in the best way to sell them. Is there an easy way for them to be evaluated by an expert so as to verify their authenticity?
I don't know who all has produced repro Bean Giants besides Ian McColl, but if these Bean Giants are repros (which I do not believe they are), then I can say with great certainty that McColl didn't make them. I have a few pairs of MColl cuffs including a Bean Giant and I will show you why I think they are not McColl's repros.

First, look at the photos listed above....look at the workmanship imparticular. Now look at the workmanship of my McColl Bean Giant.








Notice how there is a large gap where the bow arm enters the body of the cuff. Also, notice all the dents, dings, peen marks where there shouldn't be peen marks, and the unevenly peened rivits. In fact, one bow are is quite loose because the rivit has not been peened all the way. This is not the case on the Giants in question. These two cuffs were not made by the same maker and this is why I believe that the ones in question are originals and not repros. BTW, these cuffs were never used; they went from the box I received them in, to my display board, to be photographed, and back to the display board. I didn't do ANY of this damage, it was a part of the original workmanship.

Cheers, Mike