Mark Lyons
#1Hi. I was just reading an article about a new exhibit at the Houdini Museum in Appleton, Wisconsin. It is called the "A.K.A. Houdini" exhibit and one of the highlights of it shows the Metamorphosis trunk trick complete with the secret side panel that allows the magician to switch places with the assistant.
The exhibit shows some of the secrets which are pretty much common knowledge even to the public. Some magicians, famous and not so famous have been calling or writing the museum in opposition to the display, saying that it violates the magicians code of ethics and that they should stop revealing the secrets to the public and close the display.
I do not know how many other tricks are in the display, but if I had the opportunity to get over there, I would just love to have the once in a lifetime chance to see how Houdini's tricks were constructed. My own opinion is that the display is a good thing as it would give others a rare chance to see something amazing and might spark interest in budding new magicians. Even though it is open to the public, I see it as a grand magic lecture. I think that only those that take the time to travel to Wisconsin to see the exhibit have a moderate to serious interest in magic or Houdini and that the 99% of the public who does not have such an interest in magic will not learn of the secrets. How many in the general population would find themselves at the Houdini Museum in Appleton, Wisconsin by chance? Practically none. Any visitors to the museum would have had a strong desire to be there.
I think that in the case of Metamorphosis most people who have an interest in magic have the basic idea of how the trick is done and that by seeing the panel in an open state does not violate too much of the ethics code. I also believe that the real secret is the timing, showmanship, and the practice that makes the trick work not just a secret panel.
Do you guys think that this is a good thing or is something that should be compared to the Masked Magician on TV from a few years ago? Does this break the code of ethics or is it of enough historical importance for all those interested to learn from?
There are lots of escape artists and magicians who frequent this web-site. I hope that each of you responds. m
The exhibit shows some of the secrets which are pretty much common knowledge even to the public. Some magicians, famous and not so famous have been calling or writing the museum in opposition to the display, saying that it violates the magicians code of ethics and that they should stop revealing the secrets to the public and close the display.
I do not know how many other tricks are in the display, but if I had the opportunity to get over there, I would just love to have the once in a lifetime chance to see how Houdini's tricks were constructed. My own opinion is that the display is a good thing as it would give others a rare chance to see something amazing and might spark interest in budding new magicians. Even though it is open to the public, I see it as a grand magic lecture. I think that only those that take the time to travel to Wisconsin to see the exhibit have a moderate to serious interest in magic or Houdini and that the 99% of the public who does not have such an interest in magic will not learn of the secrets. How many in the general population would find themselves at the Houdini Museum in Appleton, Wisconsin by chance? Practically none. Any visitors to the museum would have had a strong desire to be there.
I think that in the case of Metamorphosis most people who have an interest in magic have the basic idea of how the trick is done and that by seeing the panel in an open state does not violate too much of the ethics code. I also believe that the real secret is the timing, showmanship, and the practice that makes the trick work not just a secret panel.
Do you guys think that this is a good thing or is something that should be compared to the Masked Magician on TV from a few years ago? Does this break the code of ethics or is it of enough historical importance for all those interested to learn from?
There are lots of escape artists and magicians who frequent this web-site. I hope that each of you responds. m
