@ Dennis: I presume there are a lot of differences between Law Enforcement in the US and in Europe but a citizen arrest is a 100% legal arrest in my opinion.
It is legal here, too. I didn't suggest otherwise. If it were, then many security blokes couldnยt do their jobs. But resisting citizen's arrest is not a crime. You have no right to assault me. If I don't want to go with you, you'll have to fight me, and if you endanger me, then I can use deadly force against you.
The store dick who ended up wrecking the jewelry display with his back, had grabbed me from behind, without previously announcing his presence. That was a potentially deadly assault. I don't know what he thought I was up to, and never bothered to find out. He was lucky. Instead of hammer fisting his nose, the move I had been trained to do was to chop the windpipe; a termination blow. That obviously would have been excessive. But you don't come up behind someone and attempt to restrain them with an arm around the neck. Presumably you and Mr. Security are smarter than that. Barney Fife obviously wasn't.
If you are polite and courteous, then we'll stand there and wait for the police to arrive. I'll even call them. I'll insist on calling them. I'll want their report and the 911 tape for the lawsuit.
Is your job worth that? Is your life?
Yes, I've worked as a so-called security officer, and have employed so-called SOs. It can be a tough, thankless job. Bottom of the ladder jobs usually are. I know what the mindset of some of them is, and it gets many of them into trouble. Generally we fired them at the first sign of a Rambo attitude. Well, the second sign. First they'd get a good counseling. But a guard who thinks he has the right and duty to be violent isn't safe to keep. Replacements are a dime a dozen.
A store security person has a tough job. They are required by their employer to make citizens arrests. Arresting a perp is a dangerous thing to do. Ask any real policeman. That's why the low-end staff do it. Because you're expendable. Get hurt, and there's plenty more who are qualified to do the job.
Screw up, make a false arrest, or improperly restrain someone, and it's your arse that's out on the wire.
I have a f(r)iend who was a store manager. He teed off the wrong people. His fault, your fault, nobody's fault. He's in a wheelchair, now. He'll die in a wheelchair. Is your job worth that? Is your life?
I also am aware that there are cops and other Law Enforcement officials who act as if citizens are there just to serve them instead the other way around. Oh well....
I'm not a cop, and don't have that attitude about cops vs citizens. They're the hired help. I certainly donยt believe that private security blokes have the right to lord it over citizens. And a security person is not a cop and certainly is not any kind of an officer, regardless of which cornflake box the badge came out of. Having delusions of status is a strategic mistake, liable to get one into trouble. Posing as something one isn't, earns one the derision of those who have earned the right to wear the insignia.
It's actually a dilemma for security people. They often give them a uniform that resembles a police uniform. Thy lie to them and tell them they are officers. This is because, by
almost impersonating a policeman, they gain a psychological edge over their opponent. It makes their job easier, and frankly, they need every advantage they can beg borrow or steal, because they really have no rights that your Grandmother doesnยt. If they actually impersonate policemen, and some do, then they become criminals.
I've seen some agencies that arm so called SOs and put them out in vehicles that look like squad cars. Them I consider to be a menace to society. I have nothing against armed guard mounts, as sometimes you have to protect yourself, but again, some people have delusions about what they are there for. It doesn't make it any easier when your boss builds those delusions into the program.
Observe Detect Deter. And stay safe out there.